Dog Food Myths Busted: What Every Dog Owner Should Know About Dog Food

Email is reader-supported. If you buy through our links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read more here.

Ensuring the health and well-being of our canine companions begins with providing them with a balanced and nutritious diet. However, the journey through dog nutrition is often clouded by a multitude of opinions, not all of which are scientifically grounded. 

From broad generalizations to deeply ingrained beliefs, dog food misconceptions are plentiful, leading to a critical need to separate fact from fiction for both our peace of mind and our dogs’ genuine health benefits. 

Dog Food Myths Busted

Unfortunately, misinformation often comes from well-meaning places – friends, family, internet articles, and even our own long-held beliefs. So, how do we sift through the noise and determine what’s actually true? 

In this article, we will tackle popular misconceptions about dog food and shine a light on the reality behind them. Think of it as a myth-busting mission dedicated to the love and care of our four-legged friends. 

Our ultimate goal is to help you make informed decisions about what goes into your pup’s bowl every day, ensuring a fulfilling and vibrant life for them. So, grab a notepad, and let’s dive into separating the tall tales from the truth in the world of dog nutrition.”

Myth # 1:Grain-Free Diets are Better

When it comes to feeding our furry companions, one prevalent belief is that grain-free diets are the optimal choice for our dogs. This idea has gained traction primarily due to current human dietary trends, especially with the rise of gluten-free diets. 

It’s only natural for us to think, “If it’s good for me, it must be good for my dog too, right?” Not necessarily. Many brands have capitalized on this belief, marketing grain-free as a premium or more natural option. However, the truth of the matter is quite different. 

The majority of dogs process grains like rice and oats without any hiccups. These grains aren’t just there to fill up the bag; they provide vital energy and nutrients. And while some dogs might have grain sensitivities, these cases are fewer than you’d think. 

Interestingly, most canine food allergies are tied to specific proteins, not grains. To top it off, recent research has even suggested potential heart health concerns with grain-free diets. 

The bottom line? Just as with our diets, it’s crucial to understand our dogs’ individual needs and not get swept up in the latest trend. Consulting with a veterinarian is always a wise step before making significant dietary changes for our beloved pets.

Myth #2: Dogs are Strictly Carnivores

A common belief among pet owners is that dogs are strictly carnivores, tailored to a diet solely of meat. But this perspective doesn’t quite align with the reality of canine nutrition. 

In truth, dogs are omnivores. While they thrive on high-quality proteins, they can also benefit from the nutrients found in vegetables, fruits, and grains. This balanced dietary approach reflects the evolutionary journey of dogs, which has seen them adapt to diverse food sources alongside humans.

So, while meat remains a pivotal part of their diet, it’s essential to recognize that a variety of foods can contribute to their overall well-being.

High Protein Diets are Best for Dogs

Myth #3: High Protein Diets are Best for Dogs

Protein plays an undeniably crucial role in a dog’s diet, supporting muscle development, maintaining skin and hair health, and providing them with energy. 

So, it’s easy to assume, “the more, the better.” But here’s the nuanced bit: just as a one-size-fits-all approach doesn’t work for us humans, it doesn’t quite fit our canine companions either.

For some dogs, especially active ones or certain breeds, a high-protein diet might be beneficial. On the flip side, pets with a more sedentary lifestyle or specific health concerns may not require as much protein. 

The essential thing to remember is balance. An excess of any nutrient, even protein, can tilt the dietary scales, possibly leading to other deficiencies or health concerns.

Myth #4: All "By-products" are Bad

There’s a common perception that “by-products” in dog food equate to inferior quality. However, this isn’t entirely accurate. By-products often include parts like the liver or spleen, which might not be appetizing for humans but are nutritious for dogs. 

It’s essential to recognize that the quality of by-products can vary. Some are indeed nutrient-rich and beneficial, while others might not be of the highest grade. 

The key is discernment: understanding the source and quality, and when in doubt, consulting with a veterinarian for guidance.

Myth #5: Raw Diets Are Always the Best

There’s been considerable chatter in pet communities about the benefits of feeding dogs a raw diet. Proponents highlight its natural approach, often comparing it to what wild canids might consume. But is raw always the right way to go?

The truth is, while raw diets can offer certain advantages, such as unprocessed nutrients, they’re not without their concerns. Potential bacterial contamination is one risk, posing health threats not just to pets but also to their owners. 

Additionally, unless carefully balanced, a raw diet might miss out on essential nutrients or proportions, potentially leading to dietary imbalances.

In essence, while raw diets have their merits, they’re not a universal solution. It’s crucial to weigh the pros and cons, consider your pet’s individual needs, and seek advice from a knowledgeable veterinarian before transitioning to such a diet.

Myth #6: Human Food is Always Harmful

This is a prevalent myth that all human food is harmful to dogs, but it’s a bit of an oversimplification.

Yes, there are definite no-nos in the human menu for dogs; chocolate, onions, and grapes are a few examples of foods that can be toxic for our furry friends. But that doesn’t mean every item from our kitchen is off-limits. 

Many human foods, like lean meats, certain vegetables, and even some fruits, can be both safe and nutritious for dogs.

Table Scraps are Good for Dogs

While it’s crucial to be aware of harmful foods, it’s equally important to recognize that not all human food is detrimental. 

A touch of research or a quick chat with your vet can shed light on what’s shareable and what’s strictly for human consumption.

Myth #7: Table Scraps are Good for Dogs

It’s a scene many of us are familiar with, wrapping up dinner and considering sharing the leftovers with our eager, tail-wagging companion waiting by our side. 

The belief that table scraps are okay, or even beneficial for dogs, has found its way into many households. But how accurate is this?

While there’s no denying the bond that forms when we share with our pets, table scraps aren’t always the best way to show our affection.

The primary concern here is consistency in nutrition. Our meals aren’t formulated with a dog’s dietary needs in mind. Some ingredients might be too rich, too spicy, or even harmful. Regularly feeding them can lead to imbalances or health issues.

However, this isn’t to say that every scrap is bad. Some pieces of lean meat or veggies might be alright in moderation. The emphasis here is on understanding what’s safe and what’s not.

Myth #8: Chewing Bones and Antlers Protect Teeth

Many of us have grown up with the image of a happy dog gnawing away at a bone, seemingly benefiting from both joy and dental hygiene. The idea that bones and antlers can act as natural toothbrushes for our canine friends is widespread. 

Chewing can, in fact, assist in reducing plaque. However, the risk comes with the hardness of bones and antlers. They can be so tough that instead of cleaning teeth, they pose a risk of breaking them. 

And that’s not the only concern. Splinters from bones can damage a dog’s internal organs, and antlers might become choking hazards if broken into smaller pieces.

While the intention behind giving our dogs bones or antlers is often a mix of providing enjoyment and dental care, it’s essential to evaluate the risks.

Expensive Food is Always Better

If dental health is the primary concern, there are safer alternatives designed specifically for dogs, which ensure dental care without the potential harm.

Myth #9: Dry Food is Better Than Wet Food

In the world of pet parenting, the debate between dry and wet dog food is a classic. Walk into any pet store, and you’ll be met with aisles of both, often leaving one to wonder which is the superior choice.

In reality, neither is categorically “better” than the other as they both have their merits. Dry kibble is often lauded for its convenience and potential dental benefits. The crunch can help reduce plaque on a dog’s teeth, and it’s also easy to store and measure.

On the flip side, wet food provides hydration and can be beneficial for dogs who might be prone to urinary tract issues or those who simply don’t drink enough water. Additionally, its rich flavor and texture can be more enticing for picky eaters.

In essence, it’s about understanding your dog’s unique needs and preferences. While some dogs might thrive on kibble, others might benefit from the moisture in wet food. 

As with many things in pet care, a tailored approach and occasional consultation with a vet go a long way.

Dry Food is Better Than Wet Food

Myth #10: Homemade Diets are Always Healthier

A homemade diet evokes images of lovingly prepared bowls brimming with fresh meats, veggies, and grains, tailored to our beloved canine’s taste buds. 

Many believe that if it’s made at home with fresh ingredients, it’s naturally superior to commercial options. But is this always the case?

While homemade diets give pet owners control over ingredients and can exclude fillers or additives, they also come with challenges. 

Achieving a balanced diet for a dog isn’t just about mixing protein, carbs, and fats. It’s about ensuring the right vitamins, minerals, and other essential nutrients are present in the right quantities.

Without proper knowledge or guidance, a well-intentioned homemade meal can inadvertently lead to nutritional gaps. Over time, these deficiencies or imbalances can impact a dog’s health.

In summary, homemade diets can be nutritious and tailored to a dog’s needs, but they require diligent research and occasional consultation with veterinarians or pet nutritionists to ensure they’re balanced and healthful.

Myth #11: Corn and Wheat are Just Fillers

There exists a prevalent belief in pet nutrition discussions that ingredients like corn and wheat serve only as fillers in dog food, contributing little to no nutritional value. This assertion merits a closer examination based on available scientific evidence.

Corn, when appropriately processed, offers essential fatty acids, proteins, and carbohydrates. These components play a role in energy production and overall health maintenance. Similarly, wheat provides dietary fiber and is an additional source of protein.

While it is crucial to acknowledge that certain canines may exhibit sensitivities to grains, it is not scientifically accurate to label these ingredients as mere “fillers.” 

Their contribution to a dog’s diet, when sourced and processed correctly, can be nutritionally substantive. 

Pet owners are encouraged to make decisions based on evidence and, when necessary, consult with veterinarians to ascertain the best dietary choices for their individual pets.

Myth #12: Expensive Food is Always Better

There’s a common belief that higher-priced dog food is of better quality. However, this is not always accurate.

The cost of dog food can be influenced by extrinsic factors unrelated to nutritional content, such as marketing campaigns, packaging innovations, or brand reputation. Thus, a higher price point does not intrinsically confirm enhanced ingredient quality or nutritional benefit.

It is important for pet owners to evaluate dog food based on its ingredient composition, source of nutrients, and comprehensive nutritional analysis. 

Sometimes, less costly foods can be just as good, nutritionally speaking, as the expensive ones.

In summary, when assessing dog food options, an emphasis on ingredient integrity and nutritional adequacy should supersede price considerations. Engaging with a veterinary nutrition specialist can further assist in making informed decisions.

Myth #13: Artificial Preservatives are Always Bad

Artificial preservatives serve a pivotal role in ensuring the longevity of dog food. Their primary function is to deter spoilage, ensuring that the product remains safe for consumption over extended periods. This in turn aids in economic and practical considerations for pet owners.

It’s vital, however, to discern between various artificial preservatives. While some may have contentious health implications, others are deemed relatively safe. 

Comprehensive research and periodic reviews by regulatory bodies contribute to these determinations.

For optimal pet health, it is advisable to familiarize oneself with individual preservative types and their potential effects.

Myth #14: A Dog's Diet Doesn't Need to Change with Age

Just like humans, dogs undergo physiological changes as they age. Puppies, with their boundless energy, have different nutritional demands compared to senior dogs, who might be less active and have slower metabolic rates. 

It’s akin to how dietary preferences and nutritional needs change for people from childhood through to their senior years.

Further, age can also bring about specific health challenges for dogs. Some might require fewer calories to prevent weight gain, while others might need more fiber or specific nutrients to support joint health, cognitive function, or organ health.

Puppies Don't Need Vitamins

In essence, a one-size-fits-all approach doesn’t apply when it comes to a dog’s diet throughout its lifespan.

Myth #15: Puppies Don't Need Vitamins

A prevalent misconception in canine nutrition pertains to the vitamin requirements of puppies. Many assume that young dogs, with their robust health and vitality, do not require additional vitamins.

In reality, puppies are in an essential phase of growth and development. This period necessitates a precise balance of nutrients, inclusive of vitamins, to ensure proper skeletal growth, organ development, and immune system fortification.

High-quality commercial puppy foods are typically formulated to cater to these specific nutritional demands. 

However, it’s erroneous to consider vitamins as non-essential. Each vitamin has a distinct role, from aiding metabolic processes to facilitating cellular functions.

For optimal puppy health, it’s paramount to adhere to a diet that encompasses all necessary vitamins in appropriate amounts.


The world of dog nutrition is constantly evolving, and as we’ve delved deep in this article, it’s evident that some widely held notions about dog food aren’t as factual as they seem. 

From misconceptions to half-truths, the journey of understanding the best for our furry friends can sometimes lead us down paths paved with misinformation.

The 15 myths we’ve debunked today highlight the necessity for dog owners to approach pet nutrition with a discerning eye and an open mind. Remember, not every trend that gains traction is rooted in science, and not every traditional feeding method is outdated. 

It’s crucial to blend our trust in reputable research with a tailored understanding of our unique pets and their specific needs.

Above all, our canine companions rely on us for their health and well-being. Making informed choices about their diet can significantly impact their quality of life, longevity, and overall happiness. 

Always be prepared to consult with veterinary and nutrition experts when in doubt, and keep yourself updated with credible information. In a world buzzing with information, separating fact from fiction isn’t just a task—it’s our responsibility to our loyal four-legged friends.

Disclaimer: All the content on this site, including information and opinions expressed herein, as well as related notes, text, videos, and images, are meant for general informational purposes only. They are not intended to offer veterinary advice, and should not be used as a replacement for veterinary diagnosis, treatment, guidance, or services. and its writers cannot be held liable or responsible for any costs, damages, or claims that may arise from the reader’s actions.